Why is detention a good punishment?

Why is detention a good punishment?

The purpose of assigning detention is to punish misbehavior. Therefore, the goal of deten- tion is to reduce future occurrences of the behavior being punished.

Are school detentions effective?

Detentions led Group 2’s behaviour to improve, but they seemed to make Group 3’s behaviour worse. Not only were detentions and suspensions ineffective, they “may have served as rewards both for students and for teachers (Atkins et al., 2002, p. 368).” So sanctions work for some students, and really don’t help others.

Is detention an effective form of punishment?

They are a staple of school discipline policies everywhere but setting detentions and making pupils miss recess are ineffective ways of punishing bad behavior, according to new research.

Why do schools still use detention?

Detention has been used to make students aware that they are not completing or doing their work, displaying correct behavior in various situations, not behaving or completing task, or having the appropriate actions in given situations. Detention is one of the most common punishments in United States.

Can a school keep my child in detention?

Detention. Teachers have the power to issue detention to pupils under 18. A school does not need the consent of a parent before issuing detention. Detention can take place during school hours and in some circumstances outside of school hours.

Why detention should not be abolished?

The Rajya Sabha has scrapped the ‘No-Detention’ policy but a lot of education activists, parents and students are extremely unhappy with this move. The Initiative’s main reason for this stand is that students cannot be blamed when they fail since and that there continues to be a lack of good teachers in the system.

Do detentions matter?

Even though there is such a thing as a record that includes your disciplinary history, most colleges don’t ask for this record. However, given that detentions are typically awarded for minor offenses, most colleges aren’t too concerned with them.

Can parents refuse after school detention?

A school does not need the consent of a parent before issuing detention. Detention can take place during school hours and in some circumstances outside of school hours.

What does detention mean in school?

School Punishment Detention. Detention is a form of punishment used in schools, where a student is required to spend extra time in school. A detention usually takes place during a period after the end of the school day.

Should schools use same-day sanctions for detention?

Same-day sanctions also improve pupils’ chances of remembering the detention at all. In some schools, even if the original offence is small, such as wearing the wrong shoes, not turning up to detention can result in as much punishment as for someone who started a fight. “Not a fair system,” says one recent school leaver from Hillingdon.

What are some stereotypical students that get detention?

In my school, the stereotypical students that got detention were those of two types. You had the children who couldn’t stop talking or were disruptive in some way in the classroom, and then you had the students who wanted to be anywhere than in the classroom and so behaved in any manner that would let them escape!

Is detention/suspension a reward or a punishment?

They found that the number of referrals over the year increased for the ‘fall + spring group’, highlighting that detention/suspension was functioning as a reward and not a punishment. This study to me sounds far too familiar in many schools. So is it not time to re-vamp the punishment system… find something that actually will benefit children?